The Absolute Best Pizza in Highland Park IL [Updated 2026]

Having explored countless pizzerias, I’ve narrowed down my favorites to four outstanding spots that truly capture the essence of what pizza should be.

Whether you're craving a classic thin crust or a hearty deep-dish, each of these places offers a unique twist that keeps locals coming back for more.

Join me as I take you on a delicious journey through mouthwatering toppings, delectable sauces, and the warm, inviting atmosphere that makes these pizzerias stand out.

Let’s dive into the best of Highland Park’s pizza scene!

Pizzeria Carina

During my culinary exploration of Highland Park's pizzerias, Pizzeria Carina stood out as a true gem. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an ambiance that perfectly balanced warmth and vibrancy, making it a delightful place to unwind with friends or family. The outstanding service was the proverbial cherry on top, with staff who seemed genuinely enthusiastic about helping me navigate the menu.

What really had my taste buds dancing was their authentic Roman-style pizza. Each bite was a celebration of fresh, high-quality ingredients, bursting with flavors that transported me straight to the streets of Italy. I savored a Margherita that showcased a beautifully charred crust—light and airy, yet robust enough to handle the fresh tomatoes and creamy mozzarella.

Moreover, one can’t overlook the impeccable cleanliness of the restaurant, which added to the overall dining experience. It's clear that Pizzeria Carina prides itself on consistency and flavor in their offerings, making every visit both a delightful discovery and a rewarding return. If you're in Highland Park and searching for something special, this pizzeria is a must-visit. Pizzeria Carina can't be missed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Dallas Metroplex.

Pizzana

From the moment I stepped into Pizzana, the vibrant atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm, cheesy hug. Their Neapolitan-style pizza, with its perfectly charred crust and fresh toppings, is a true culinary delight. I indulged in the Margherita, which showcased a beautiful balance of velvety mozzarella and zesty tomato sauce. Each bite ignited my taste buds, leaving me craving more. The service was delightful, with staff who clearly share a passion for pizza. If you're in Highland Park and looking to satisfy your pizza cravings, Pizzana is undoubtedly a slice of heaven you don’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Dallas.

Fachini

Fachini is a delightful find in Highland Park! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and savory toppings. Their thin-crust pizza is a must-try—each slice is a perfect balance of crispy and chewy. The house-made sauce bursts with flavor, complemented by top-notch ingredients. I particularly enjoyed the truffle mushroom combo; it redefines indulgence! The cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for a casual night out. If you're seeking a place where quality meets creativity, Fachini undoubtedly deserves a spot on your pizza pilgrimage! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Dallas Fort Worth.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Turtle Creek

Indulging in a slice at Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Turtle Creek was nothing short of a delightful adventure! The crust was perfectly charred, offering that irresistible balance of crunch and chew. I opted for the Mister O1 signature pizza, and each bite was a symphony of flavors—melted mozzarella, vibrant basil, and a rich, tangy sauce danced together beautifully. The toppings were fresh, adding a delightful burst of flavor. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for pizza lovers. If you're on the hunt for an extraordinary experience in Highland Park, look no further—this place is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Dallas.